Bigger Resilience · Principle 19 of 21

Calculate Your Risks

Is the safe option really that safe?

8 minute readRisk listTeam version included
At the chart table, checking the radio and instruments
From the bookProvided you've done your own thinking, pulled apart the biases and applied your own cold hard logic, bet on yourself. Not in a throw caution to the wind way.Chapter 19, The Big Bold Mindset®
In short

How do cognitive biases affect decision making and risk?

Biases cloud your judgement of risk, so you may avoid choices that are far less risky than they seem, or take ones laden with hidden risks. People fear sharks, which kill about 10 a year, more than unhealthy diets, linked to about 11 million deaths. Becoming aware of your biases is the first step.

Caspar’s story

Most people thought we were crazy.

In 2014 my wife and I set off to sail the world with our three children, all under ten. Most people thought we were crazy. Many still do.

We spent years preparing. We listed every single risk and held each one up to the light. Was it real or imagined? How likely was it? What could we do to reduce it? What training did we need?

Only when we'd worked through every risk did we decide to go. Not in a throw caution to the wind way, but grounded and built with careful consideration and logic.

Where are you?

How good is your decision-making?

1

How do you check whether your past decisions were good ones?

2

Which biases are most likely to be acting on you right now?

3

What decision are you putting off?

The science of bias

We're bad at judging risk.

Which is the bigger risk: sharks, roads or an unhealthy diet? Most people know the order. Few guess the size of the gaps.

Unhealthy diets
11m
Road traffic
1.35m
Sharks
~10
Deaths a year worldwide. World Health Organization; International Shark Attack File.

Biases to watch for

Confirmation bias

We look for evidence we're right and miss what says we're wrong.

Anchoring

The first number or story we hear sticks, even when new facts arrive.

Loss aversion

Losing hurts more than winning feels good, so we play too safe.

Big Bold Leaders

Deep Mind: the moves no human would make

2016Deep Mind takes on Go master Lee Sedol in South Korea
MillionsHundreds of millions watched around the world
LogicIt can think many moves further ahead than the human brain

Deep Mind made a series of moves that made no sense to the experts watching. Lee Sedol was confused by them. A set of moves no human would make, that seemed destined to lose the game, and that ended with Deep Mind winning it.

You'll struggle to out-think an AI. But you can out-think other humans, if you strip out the biases and use cold, hard logic.

There is nothing in life that is risk free.Caspar Craven
The tool

The risk list

The same process the Craven family used before sailing the world. Use it on any big decision.

1

List the options

Including doing nothing. Is the safe option really safe?

2

List every risk

Don't hold back. Get them all on paper.

3

Real or imagined?

Hold each risk up to the light. Is it fact or fear?

4

How likely?

Give each one a rough probability.

5

Reduce it

What steps, training or resources would lower it?

6

Decide and learn

Make the call. Afterwards, review how biases played a part.

Try this week

List the risks on one decision

Take one decision you're putting off. List every risk. Mark each real or imagined, give it a rough probability, and write one step to reduce it.

Take it to your team

Strip the bias out of a team decision

Diverse views and open challenge are the best defence against bias.

Name the decision and every option, including doing nothing.
List risks for each. Mark real or imagined, and which bias might be at play.
Design the quickest experiment to test the biggest unknown.
Work with Caspar

Run this with Caspar in the room

The 20-minute version above works on its own. With Caspar in the room it goes further: he brings the stories behind Calculate Your Risks, then takes your team through the exercise live, so everyone leaves with an experiment they have chosen themselves.

  • Creator of The Big Bold Mindset®
  • Leadership keynote speaker: events in over 38 countries, for over 400 organisations going through change
  • 2x round the world sailor
  • Former CFO (multiple exits) and an Associate Director at KPMG

“Hager Group invited Caspar to talk to 500 people about resilience and how to adapt in times of crisis. I wish I could’ve heard him talk all day.”

Head of Diversity and InclusionHager Group

Caspar has worked with organisations including BAE Systems, Burberry, GSK, Intuit, INEOS Styrolution, Johnson & Johnson, Nuffield Health, Pearson, Sage, Suntory and Thales.

Questions people ask

Questions about Calculate Your Risks

What are the most common cognitive biases in decision making?

Caspar sees five showing up most: confirmation bias, seeking only evidence that supports what you believe; anchoring bias, placing too much weight on the first thing you hear; loss aversion; availability bias, judging likelihood by what you easily recall; and overconfidence bias.

How can you reduce bias when making decisions?

Be aware you have biases and have the humility to accept you may be wrong. Seek diverse perspectives, slow down where you can, use structured frameworks, run experiments to test assumptions, stay open to criticism and reflect on outcomes so you learn fast.

How do you assess the risks of a big decision?

List every risk and hold each one up to the light. Is it real or imagined? What are the chances of it happening? What steps, resources and training can mitigate it? Caspar’s family did this for years before sailing the world in 2014.

The Big Bold Mindset book cover
Go deeper

This is Chapter 19 of The Big Bold Mindset®

The full chapter has the whole story, the research and more leaders who lived it.

Rated 5.0 out of 5 by readers on Amazon.